How To Turn Flyby Visitors Into Brand Loyalists

Fact checked by Vahe Arabian
Vahe Arabian

Founder and Editor in Chief of State of Digital Publishing. My vision is to provide digital publishing and media professionals a platform to collaborate and promote their efforts, my passion is to uncover talent and… Read more

Edited by Andrew Kemp
Andrew Kemp

Andrew joined the State of Digital Publishing team in 2021, bringing with him more than a decade and a half of editorial experience in B2B publishing. His career has spanned the technology, natural resources, financ…Read more


Ben specialises in digital ad serving and RTB systems and has in-depth experience in Google Ad Manager, AppNexus, Atlas (Facebook), Helios IQ and more. Prior...Read more

Ben Erdos, Chief Services Officer, Total Media Solutions

Website visitors come in various shapes and sizes.

There are brand enthusiasts who log on regularly and are willing to pay for a premium service, or those loyal visitors, who are ever so slightly less enthusiastic, but still visit occasionally to dip their toes in.

And then there are flyby users: visitors that are there only fleetingly, often for their first — and only — time. 

All of these users behave differently and have varying expectations from a publisher’s digital offering. While a focus on loyal visitors can seem the key to success, enhancing the experience of flyby users is key to growing audiences.

So how can these flyby users be converted into ardent brand enthusiasts?

Spinning a Web

Capturing flyby users is an important part of any publisher’s audience growth strategy. With these visitors coming from website click-throughs or social media, their attention has to be grabbed immediately — it takes the average visitor 2.6 seconds to form an impression of a website.

It’s clear that first impressions matter. Not only does a site have to look visually stimulating, but it needs to look reliable. Three-quarters of a visitor’s perception about the credibility of a website comes from its design. Optimising user experience (UX) with a crisp, clear layout, and concise, easy-to-use functions also goes a long way.

Speed is also of the essence with flyby users. Nearly half of visitors expect a webpage to load in two seconds or under, with bounce rates soaring if it takes more than three seconds to load.

Tools such as Google’s Lighthouse and GTmetrix are useful to audit website speed performance and can suggest changes to publishers that improve load times.

While flyby users might read an article or watch a video from start to finish, it’s more likely they’ll skim the webpage lightly before clicking out. With a human’s attention span now only around eight seconds long, there is only a very short period to entice users to stay onsite.

Placing highly visible internal links to related content not only increases the chance of flyby users staying longer, but also gives them a better insight into a publisher’s unique offering — and enhances the chance of them becoming a return visitor.

Growing Closer

As the loss of third party-data looms closer, a majority of publishers are putting subscriptions at the core of their revenue strategy. To ensure the success of this, publishers will not only have to capture the attention of flyby users, but will have to convince them — and already regular visitors — to part with their hard earned cash.

While engaging content needs to be a priority, there are a number of ways publishers can enhance their subscription offerings.

Data-Backed Content

First-party data is seen by both publishers and advertisers as a way to fill the gap left by the loss of cookies.

Publishers can harness this data further to inform their content strategy. Metrics such as “most viewed pages” and “time spent on page” allows publishers to view what content is chiming with audiences and tailor future content appropriately, while retaining a unique voice.

Building the Right Paywall

There are multiple paywall options for publishers, and deciding how to implement one is key to a successful subscriber-based strategy. Hard paywalls can be successful for publishers with large but niche audiences, such as the Financial Times, but this hard lock-out may not work for smaller publishers — especially those looking to grow brand awareness. 

The New York Times has led the way with metered or soft paywalls, recently announcing its subscriber base has grown to 10 million. These more dynamic forms of paywalls can be hard to implement and may take some time before the right cost-to-content balance is reached, but prove an effective middle ground for growing reach and increasing subscriber revenue.

A further method may be to offer subscribers exclusive content. In-depth examination of audience data is invaluable when building a successful subscription model.

Building relationships with audiences is not a quick process, and there are no quick cookie-cutter answers.

Flyby users represent growth for all publishers, but this growth needs to be continually nurtured with patience, nuance and an analytical mindset. Not all of them will become loyal, paid subscribers but that does not mean they should be shrugged off.

Even the briefest visitors can be a source of valuable first-party data.

Disclaimer: The views, opinions and ideas expressed in this post belong to the author/s and do not necessarily reflect those held by State of Digital Publishing.



Learn proven strategies to maximize traffic to your digital publication by leveraging tried and tested technical and content SEO strategies.


Related posts

Latest Membership Insights

online course

Publisher SEO

Learn a technical and content SEO strategy that helps digital publishers increase their organic traffic by 100-500%.

online course

Publisher SEO

Learn a technical and content SEO strategy that helps digital publishers increase their organic traffic by 100-500%.